Is holding students after the bell a war crime?

Contents

No, holding students after the bell is not a war crime. It is a disciplinary action that some schools may use for tardiness or other infractions.

For more information, see below

Holding students after the bell is a disciplinary action taken by some schools for tardiness or other infractions. It is not considered a war crime. According to an article by The Institute for War and Peace Reporting, “a war crime is any act that constitutes a serious violation of the laws of war that gives rise to individual criminal responsibility.” Clearly, holding students after the bell does not fit within that definition.

In addition, holding students after the bell is a relatively common punishment used in schools. It provides a consequence for students who are habitually late or have other disciplinary issues. However, it is important for schools to ensure that the punishment is not excessive and does not harm the student’s education. According to the National Association of Secondary School Principals, “any disciplinary measure, when employed, should be applied in a fair and consistent manner and be designed to protect individual rights.”

Interesting facts on the topic include:

In some countries, holding students after the bell is illegal. In France, for example, schools are not allowed to keep students after the end of the day without the approval of the student’s parents.
In the United States, some schools have received criticism for using holding students after the bell as a punishment. Critics argue that it can be detrimental to the student’s education and does not address underlying issues that may be causing the tardiness or other disciplinary problems.
There are a variety of other punishments that schools may use for disciplinary issues, including detention, suspension, or expulsion.

As former U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan said, “Effective school discipline is not about punishment, it’s about supporting children and young people in making good choices.” Schools should consider the impact of holding students after the bell and ensure that it is used appropriately and fairly.

Table: Disciplinary Actions in Schools

Punishment	Description
Holding students after the bell	Keeping students after the end of the day for tardiness or other disciplinary issues
Detention	Extra time spent in school after hours for similar disciplinary issues
Suspension	Giving the student a period of time out of school
Expulsion	Removing the student from school entirely

IMPORTANT: The ideal response to — is Sewanee University a good school?

See additional response choices

The Geneva Convention only applies during a time of war and conflict. The Geneva Laws were established not to tell schools that it’s illegal to keep kids after the bell, but to tell all countries that both military and civilians must be treated humanely even at a time of war.

Holding students after the bell is not a war crime. The Geneva Laws were established to tell all countries that both military and civilians must be treated humanely even at a time of war, and do not apply to the classroom unless the United States happens to be occupied by an enemy from outside the country. There isn’t a law against keeping people in class after the bell rings, but it’s important that teachers don’t abuse their power to keep students in class after the bell. According to Article 33 of the Geneva Convention, a person should not be punished for a crime that they did not commit, but this law only applies to times of war and conflict and does not apply to students.

The Geneva Laws were established not to tell schools that it’s illegal to keep kids after the bell, but to tell all countries that both military and civilians must be treated humanely even at a time of war. So, unless the United States happens to be occupied by an enemy from outside the country, then this law does not apply to the classroom.

Is holding students after the bell a war crime? There isn’t a law against keeping people in class after the bell rings. There are different rules about the bell in your school’s policy. It’s important that teachers don’t abuse their power to keep students in class after the bell.

According to Article 33 of the Geneva Convention, a person should not be punished for a crime that they did not commit. This law seems to apply when a teacher detains the entire class or collective punishments because of one or two students. The Geneva Convention law only applies to times of war and conflict and does not apply to students.

A video response to “Is holding students after the bell a war crime?”

In the video “How one journalist risked her life to hold murderers accountable”, Christina Greer highlights the story of Ida B. Wells, a young journalist who investigated lynching in the late 1800s despite receiving death threats and having her newspaper presses destroyed. Wells’ research and public speeches drew international attention to the horrors of lynching and helped to hold those responsible accountable.

IMPORTANT: Question — how can I watch college football without a TV provider?

You will probably be interested in this

Is it legal to keep students after the final bell?

In reply to that: There are no direct laws against keeping people in class after the bell rings. Also, your school’s policy or regulations can specifically say different rules about the bell. However, teachers must be careful not to abuse their power to keep students after the bell.

Does the Geneva Convention apply to schools?

Answer: Education is principally protected in international humanitarian law by the Geneva Conventions and its Additional Protocols. The key obligations include: Protection of civilian persons and objects including schools, teachers and students.

Is collective punishment in school a war crime?

Response to this: International humanitarian law prohibits collective punishment of prisoners of war or other protected persons for acts committed by individuals during an armed conflict. The imposition of collective punishment is a war crime.

Does school break the Geneva Convention?

Response will be: The Geneva Conventions were developed as general rules of war in the treatment of prisoners of war and refugees. If your classroom is not at war, the Conventions do not apply.

Is it legal to keep students after the bell?

Answer will be: It is actually legalto keep students after the bell. There are no direct laws against keeping people in class after the bell rings. Also, your school’s policy or regulations can specifically say different rules about the bell. However, teachers must be careful not to abuse their power to keep students after the bell.

Can a teacher keep a student in class after the bell rings?

Answer will be: There are no direct laws against keeping people in class after the bell rings. Also, your school’s policy or regulations can specifically say different rules about the bell. However, teachers must be careful not to abuse their power to keep students after the bell. Many students are curious whether the bell or teacher dismisses them from class.

Should a teacher and school bell work in unison?

Ideally, a teacher and school bell should work in unison. However, it doesn’t always work that way. Sometimes teachers hold students after the bell because they: Holding students after the bell is an acceptable punishment (legally speaking). Most schools won’t blink an eye at keeping a class late.

Is schooling an armed conflict?

As an answer to this: Schooling is not armed conflict of any sort. Unless your teacher is from the opposing army and you’re in the middle of a war and the holding after the bell has huge damages to you, the Geneva Conventions don’t apply. Article 86 of the Geneva Convention says that students aren’t people, though.

Is it legal to keep students after the bell?

As a response to this: It is actually legalto keep students after the bell. There are no direct laws against keeping people in class after the bell rings. Also, your school’s policy or regulations can specifically say different rules about the bell. However, teachers must be careful not to abuse their power to keep students after the bell.

Can a teacher keep a student in class after the bell rings?

Answer to this: There are no direct laws against keeping people in class after the bell rings. Also, your school’s policy or regulations can specifically say different rules about the bell. However, teachers must be careful not to abuse their power to keep students after the bell. Many students are curious whether the bell or teacher dismisses them from class.

Should a teacher and school bell work in unison?

Answer to this: Ideally, a teacher and school bell should work in unison. However, it doesn’t always work that way. Sometimes teachers hold students after the bell because they: Holding students after the bell is an acceptable punishment (legally speaking). Most schools won’t blink an eye at keeping a class late.

Is schooling an armed conflict?

In reply to that: Schooling is not armed conflict of any sort. Unless your teacher is from the opposing army and you’re in the middle of a war and the holding after the bell has huge damages to you, the Geneva Conventions don’t apply. Article 86 of the Geneva Convention says that students aren’t people, though.